Google vs. the Library: Student Preferences and Perceptions When Doing Research Using Google and a Federated Search Tool
نویسنده
چکیده
Federated searching was once touted as the library world’s answer to Google, but ten years since federated searching technology’s inception, how does it actually compare? This study focuses on undergraduate student preferences and perceptions when doing research using both Google and a federated search tool. Students were asked about their preferences using each search tool and the perceived relevance of the sources they found using each search tool. Students were also asked to self-assess their online searching skills. The findings show that students believe they possess strong searching skills, are able to find relevant sources using both search tools, but actually prefer the federated search tool to Google for doing research. Thus, despite federated searching’s limitations, students see the need for it, libraries should continue to offer federated search (especially if a discovery search tool is not available), and librarians should focus on teaching students how to use federated search and Google more effectively.
منابع مشابه
Book review: Carol Smallwood (ed.), The Complete Guide to Using Google in Libraries: Research, User Applications, and Networking, Volume 2
Google as one of the symbols of digital revolution has been influencing the world of searching from different aspects. Moreover, its place as a tool for information retrieval and research, and as a research topic for end-users and researchers is well known. As a result of Google’s pioneership in providing and changing, or to be precise, optimizing its services, it is being utilized by various i...
متن کاملdbWiz: open source federated searching for academic libraries
Faced with the choice between multiple subscription databases, each with a different interface and search functions, and the simplicity of Google, college and university students are increasingly finding their research materials on the open web. Federated searching provides one way that academic libraries can begin to win back some of these novice users, and ensure they are finding the highest ...
متن کاملDesigning an Effective Enterprise Search Solution
The Google Search Appliance provides quite a few traditionally requested enterprise search features out-of-the-box (OOTB). Even though the appliance fits the hardware plug-and-play model, it provides a flexible framework for integrating with external systems such as content management systems, document management systems, security systems, federated search and both Google and non-Google service...
متن کاملSearching in the Wild: Observing Information-Seeking Behavior in a Discovery Tool
Introduction Knowing students’ preference for single-input search engines such as Google, libraries have been turning to so-called “discovery tools,” providing a Googlelike search box for finding and accessing library content. Students, however, often lack understanding of the differences between Google and a discovery tool, not grasping that underneath the Google-like smokescreen is a complex ...
متن کاملApplying SPARQL-DQP for Federated SPARQL Querying over Google Fusion Tables
Google Fusion Tables (GFT) is a data management, integration and visualization service provided by Google. Users can upload their structured data, integrate it with other people’s data, and visualize it on various tools provided, such as Google Maps, charts or graphs. Every GFT table constitutes a data silo that is not commonly linked to other data sources. A way to enable data to be linked and...
متن کامل